LIFE IS SWEETER HERE
Good food, sweet treats, and a place where everyone feels welcome.
Pull up a chair, grab something to Eat, and stay awhile
Cheesecakes • Bakery • Coffee Bar • Breakfast • Lunch • Candy & Gift Shop • In House Florist · Pop Up Artisan’s · events
Welcome to Guilty Pleasures Cafe, where the air is light and sweet, the atmosphere is nostalgic and the ideas are a bit quirky! What started 20 years ago with creative Italian-style cheesecakes, has grown into a gathering place filled with nostalgia, candy, fresh breads, pastries, breakfast, lunch, and plenty of sweet surprises waiting behind the counter.
Whether you’re stopping in for morning breakfast & coffee, grabbing lunch with friends, picking up a cheesecake for a celebration, or staying for live music or special events, it’s a lot of happiness all under one roof. If you can imagine it, we can create it!
Marvelous Surprises Await You…
New Location
1 Depot Street
Washingtonville, NY 10992
Hours
Wed–Sat 7:30am–6pm
Sunday 7:30am–5pm
Phone
Upcoming Experiences
-
![]()
WCE Fundraiser
TBA
An interactive session for makers and thinkers to collaborate, connect, and spark new ideas.
-
![]()
Libuse - In-House Florist
Our in house florist Meraki Art by Libuse brings the color and creativity with fresh flowers, custom balloons, and one of a kind arrangements for any celebration you can dream up.
-
![]()
Saturday Morning Cartoons
TBA
Join us Saturday mornings for an 80s throwback with classic cartoons, hot breakfast, and family fun that feels just like the good old days.
Book Our Event Space
Looking for a space that’s a little more memorable than the usual banquet room? Our event space is flexible, creative, and ready to host everything from relaxed gatherings to lively celebrations—with great food, sweet treats, and a little Guilty Pleasures magic built right in.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
We’re very real and very local—come visit our store, say hello, and maybe leave with something delicious.
1 Depot St, Washintonville, NY 10992
-
Not all at once, but we keep the case full of rotating flavors worth coming back for.
-
Possibly—we’re always open to great pop up ideas, so send us the details.
Apply Here
-
You can visit us Wednesday through Saturday from 8–5 and Sundays 8–3 for breakfast, cheesecake, and a good excuse to stay awhile.